Content-Type: text/html; charset=ISO-8859-1
Query
COPYING - IN TAMIL FILM HISTORY
Topic started by s.senthilkumar (@ 203.197.154.163) on Mon Jan 24 07:23:36 EST 2000.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
i think "copying" is there for a long time in tamil film history.Here we discuss the tamil songs copied from others.
For a compilation of copied/inspired songs: http://copied.tfmpage.com
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: Music4ever (@ )
on: Wed Nov 24 14:29:49 EST 2004
Is the 7G rainbow colony song "Kann pesum vaarthaigal purivadhillai" inspired from a song in Jodi ("ennai kollai ittu pogira azhage vaa")?
There is a song sung by ARR in Swades. I think ARR cannot forget the old Tamil song "vandha naal mudhal indha naal varai vaanam maaravillai". Listen to both. The Swades song has traces of the tamil number.
- From: virus (@ 80.125.235.53)
on: Wed Nov 24 14:53:45 EST 2004
ya Music4ever,
me too i felt like that
r u 100 %
correcte
- From: Sara (@ )
on: Fri Dec 3 04:39:20 EST 2004
Rahman's "Enna vilai Azhahe?" from Kadhalar dhinam from a tamil old song "Thanga pathakkathin melai..." is another copy definitely.
- From: dinesh (@ 218.111.208.182)
on: Fri Dec 3 06:24:46 EST 2004
Sara,from what movie is that song Thanga pathakkathin melai from?
- From: dinesh (@ 218.111.208.182)
on: Fri Dec 3 06:25:25 EST 2004
music4eva,this song "vandha naal mudhal indha naal varai vaanam maaravillai from what movie ?
- From: zz (@ 203.145.176.177)
on: Fri Dec 3 08:29:14 EST 2004
Paava Mannippu...
Its like finding lemon taste in our Kichadi...Hey God...its not a lemon Achaar...its kichadi...so give credit to kichadi not lemon.
Purinjidhaaaa:(((((
- From: dinesh (@ 218.111.208.182)
on: Fri Dec 3 09:03:34 EST 2004
nee mental mari pesure
- From: Sara (@ 205.228.12.39)
on: Mon Dec 6 01:49:30 EST 2004
Hey, What happened to raaga.com..For the past one week ( Dec 1st week) , we could nt get into the site, and now the site goes to someother page something like 'Russian Aids association'... What really happened to that ..any one knows?
- From: paran (@ 203.123.16.92)
on: Mon Dec 6 05:04:51 EST 2004
Sara...
that was the result of poor domain management...
it seems the Russian Aids Association have booked that domain and waited for current domain registration of raaga.com expires...and those web master at raaga...didn't bother to pre-order the domain before it expires i think...ha ha ha...
- From: Ahmed Sajith (@ 61.1.250.128)
on: Tue Dec 7 15:01:36 EST 2004
DEVA IS INDIAS BIGGEST COPYCAT.HIS COPIES RANGE FROM R D BURMAN,BOB MARLEY,LAXMIKANT PYARELAL to JUNOON....NADEEM SHRAVAN AND ANU MALIK!!!!!
I HATE THAT F****IN A*****E.
HOW COME U TAMILIANS LET SUCH A PRICK LOOSE
- From: Malik Ghouse (@ 203.200.216.62)
on: Wed Dec 8 00:04:30 EST 2004
Ahmed
I dont know where you are from - nots ure whether you are a follower of the Bombay Pirates,Andhra IR-Fan-MusicDirectors' mandali, or any other place.
But if it comes to talk about letting loose copy monsters, you would be throwing stones from glasshouses (considering you seem to think Nadeem Robber Khan and Anu thief Malik are on the other side of divide than Deva).
Go verify the credentials of these nincompoops.
As for Deva, he has been pilloried enough in TFM to have accumulated shame for seven generations unlike your bombay where pygmies like above-mentioned thieves are considered the composers of the century!
- From: arrowhill (@ 4.14.105.162)
on: Sat Dec 11 15:55:33 EST 2004
Another direct copy By Deva:
Starting violin piece from "Annamalai Annamalai.. aassai vechen ennamaley" song from Annamalai is a direct lift from Beethoven Symphony #5 (1st movement, listen from the 54th second of the piece)
- From: jed (@ 210.211.179.100)
on: Mon Dec 13 19:49:25 EST 2004
kan pesum varthai purivathillai song from 7g rainbow colony also has another interesting source. Just hum " kuchi kuchi rakama ponnu venum" from bombay and see, and You will notice the similarity between the two songs
- From: rajasaranam (@ 61.246.88.67)
on: Tue Dec 14 08:08:17 EST 2004
'Kan paesum varthaigal purivathillai' by YSR is copied frm "Enai kollai ittu pogum azhagae vaa" which was recycled by ARR from his old hit "Kuchi Kuchi Rakkamma ponnu vaenum" .....
hmmmm... this amateur Copycat YSR copying from the Professional Copycat ARR is no wonder but someone come up with the original Source of Inspiration :-)
- From: zz (@ 203.145.176.177)
on: Tue Dec 14 08:08:51 EST 2004
Message from IR Yahoo Group (interesting and sounds true)
---------------------------
check for yourself
-----------------------
Hi,
Really so sorry to post abt IR copy songs . But my mind keep
killing me why IR did like this . This is true . Raja sir had copied
the song 'Riding along in my automobile' of Chuck Berry fully to the
song "attama pattam ... nadigan yenru mariyachu ..povdar ..." of flim
Nadigan (1980) . 'Riding along in my automobile' came in 1964 ...
U can listen to the music in the below link,
http://www.mamarocks.com/no_particular_place.htm
Like this some atleast 10 songs , I feel he has copied . why he is
doing like this ? Please someone clear my doubt . The other songs are
1.bam bam bam ... arambam...perinbam from...starting music ...
[michal madana kamaraj]
2.Kannavu kannum valkai yavum from some hindi song ...
3.Even sethu ....malaiyin vedanai ...starting music ...before song
lyrics come .... i heard the simillar music in V channel once ...
Please comment on this .
- From: Jacky (@ 61.2.36.191)
on: Tue Dec 14 09:52:14 EST 2004
I was just wondering about YSR's interlude lift (Vayathuku vandhom) from MJ's they dunn care about us!
Like father, like son :)
- From: F e r r a r i (@ 192.138.110.8)
on: Tue Dec 14 10:08:15 EST 2004
kuchi kuchi raakamma ponnu venum
kaNN pesum vaarthaigal theriyaadha :-p
- From: Guess Me (@ 202.83.37.14)
on: Tue Dec 14 11:16:48 EST 2004
IR is a copycat too. Cant believe :)
- From: Guess Me (@ 202.83.37.14)
on: Tue Dec 14 15:01:03 EST 2004
Wow. IR has really did something here. Those who havent listened to the songs, here are they.
http://www.musicindiaonline.com/l/26/s/movie_name.4981/
There you will find the tamil song by IR
And for the english song, I finished uploading it just now. Click the link below to download (only 1.9MB)
http://up1.fastuploads.info/chuck_berry.mp3
IR has done a good amount of work on the english song to make it tamil. Definitely not something you would expect from a person referred by his fans as "Maestro". Shame on you.
I have always wondered what made YSR lift some english songs as such to tamil (for example, 3 ballant lifts in Kadhal Kondein) that too at the early stages of his career. Looks like his father must be an inspiration for him.
- From: nirmal (@ 61.11.73.203)
on: Wed Dec 15 06:31:38 EST 2004
Manmathan Songs an Back gruond musics are all copied from english movie like mission impossible, end of days etc.,
- From: music-man (@ 61.2.33.51)
on: Mon Dec 20 12:38:11 EST 2004
Not only from Mission Impossible,but also traces of the pop album "AQUA".
- From: ag (@ 67.94.168.186)
on: Mon Dec 20 13:58:01 EST 2004
- From: arrahman (@ 203.197.138.163)
on: Tue Dec 21 01:12:00 EST 2004
of all the mds, i have not seen anyone who copied more than arr. u guys call him a music director.
he is just a music assembler. perhaps he is following bharathy's words:
"sendriduveer ettu thikkum; kalai chelvangal yavum konarnthingu serpeer"
arrahman
- From: dinesh (@ 60.48.80.114)
on: Tue Dec 21 02:28:32 EST 2004
SOME 1 is JELOUSE!!
- From: JP (@ 203.123.16.124)
on: Tue Dec 21 04:23:10 EST 2004
dinesh,
mistyping "JELOUSE" and become something else..and BB might think that you are trying to bring obscenity into the forum?
- From: Guess Me (@ 202.83.34.0)
on: Tue Dec 21 06:09:48 EST 2004
It is not jealous dinesh, it is saddism. The pleasure earned by underplaying someone's acheivements.
- From: copycat (@ 70.25.196.18)
on: Wed Dec 22 04:45:26 EST 2004
soooo whaaaaat.......!!!!
- From: the truth (@ 61.247.247.69)
on: Sat Dec 25 03:52:30 EST 2004
A dangerous trend has emerged in Tamil films where tunes from successful Telugu hit numbers are borrowed, mainly on the request of our superstars.
Vijay’s latest Tirupachi, has two tunes that are borrowed from Chiranjeevi’s Shankardada MBBS with music by Devi Sri Prasad and another from Pawan Kalyan's Gudumba Shankar. The remaining three songs in the film are composed by Dhina.
The hit number in the film picturised on Vijay and Trisha in South Africa, “Kannung Kannundhan...” is Pawan Kalyan’s hot number from Gudumba Shankar, which had Mani Sharma’s music. And the songs composed by Dhina are all mass numbers which are not being appreciated by Vijay fans.
However producer R.B.Chowdary has given credit to the respective music directors for their tunes. Remember that music director Srikanth Deva had recently walked away with the credit for the catchy tunes like “Neeye Neeye…” and “Ayyo Ayyo…” in M.Kumaran Son of Mahalakshmi, which were borrowed tunes from the Telugu original Amma Nana O Tamil Ammayi.
Now the latest we hear is that Vidyasagar is under tremendous pressure from superstar Rajnikanth to accomodate a song from the Kannada film Aapthamitra for its Tamil remake Chandramukhi.
At this rate, Tamil hit songs will soon be a remix of Telugu chartbusters!
if this is the case why blame the music directors
Want to post a response?
Back to the Forum